Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Carter's avatar

I'm not sure I agree that it's a question of rail vs car. Frankly American urban environments are the worst in the world, precisely because they are built for cars and not people. Freeways and parking lots do not make for a livable human environment.

I've spent quite a bit of time living in cities that prioritized pedestrian access, and made extensive use of subways, light rail, etc. in order to facilitate movement and render cars less necessary. In general, it's simply incomparable to the experience of navigating the typical American city, which is by contrast nerve-wracking and alienating.

Then of course there's the traffic jam issue. Spending 2-4 hours a day, every day, sitting in traffic as you commute back and forth between your suburban domicile and your job, is no way to live.

Really, it's a question of the right tech for the right purpose. For movement outside of our between cities, cars are ideal. For movement within cities, rail, bicycle, and the old-fashioned human leg are best suited ... at least if you want your cities to be worth living in. When cities are designed for cars, they cease to be destinations, and merely become extensions of the road.

The problem is really this totalitarian urge to control movement by putting permission gates at every entry point to the transportation network. We let them get away with it in the airports, thus establishing precedent. Now they want the same at train and bus stations, and moreover to put kill switches in cars. If they get the latter cars will no longer be a symbol of freedom. I doubt they'll just use it to shut down drunk driving or political dissidents (eg the Trucker Convoy would have been stopped cold by this). They'll also use it to geo-limit vehicles a la ULEZ: preventing people from driving beyond a certain range, or from accessing certain destinations.

Expand full comment
Fat Rabbit Iron's avatar

I'd like you to explain why we should build a mass transit system in a small town with a centralized population.

Oh I could give you an answer. But the only ones who'd understand it would be you and me.

Is there anything the Simpsons didn't predict?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ag61WDlPJU

Expand full comment
32 more comments...

No posts